Skip to main content

Bengals exposed a Robert Spears-Jennings problem Steelers didn’t know they had

ByTommy Jaggi
Pittsburgh Steelers safety Robert Spears-Jennings
Pittsburgh Steelers safety Robert Spears-Jennings | Joe Sargent/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Steelers had no shortage of problems in their disgraceful Week 10 Sunday Night Football loss against the Cincinnati Bengals. As bad as Aaron Rodgers and the offense played, the defense somehow found a way to be worse—and the pass defense was egregious.

Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow carved up the Steelers for 409 yards and four touchdowns through the air. Leading up to the game, I predicted Asante Samuel Jr. would cause issues for Pittsburgh's defense. But now, the Steelers may have a Robert Spears-Jennings problem they didn't see coming.

Spears-Jennings, the Steelers' seventh-round rookie draft pick, stepped up in his role in the secondary in Week 4, when veteran Rayshawn Jenkins struggled against the Browns (and was later released by the team).

Entering the Steelers' Week 9 bye, Spears-Jennings was one of the top-rated rookies in the entire NFL. But that changed in a hurry when he came face-to-face with Burrow and the Bengals in Week 10.

Pittsburgh Steelers rookie safety Robert Spears-Jennings might be a liability against good competition

Against the Bengals, Spears-Jennings routinely found himself out of position, which led to numerous big plays for Burrow and Cincinnati's offense. Though he was only credited with allowing two catches for 24 yards in Week 10, the all-22 film showed that he was routinely out of position and late to the spot.

Because of this, Spears-Jennings earned a dismal 29.9 overall grade from Pro Football Focus on Sunday Night Football, including a 31.5 coverage grade [$]. Though the rookie remains one of the best and most consistent tacklers in Pittsburgh's secondary, we witnessed him get exposed in coverage.

Now, it's making us question everything we thought we know about the rookie.

Were his previous performances just a fluke? It's possible. I don't want to take away from the impressive play we've seen from Spears-Jennings in the first half of the season, but there's a major factor nobody is talking about with him (and the secondary in general).

Since taking on a bigger role in Week 5, Spears-Jennings has had remarkably favorable quarterback matchups against Daniel Jones, Jalon Daniels, Tyler Shough, and Deshaun Watson. It wasn't until Week 10 that he was tasked with slowing down a top-shelf QB... and it did not go well.

To be fair, nearly everyone in the Steelers' secondary struggled—it wasn't just Spears-Jennings. However, we might have gotten an inflated assessment of the player he actually is based on the bad quarterbacks he's faced and the overall easy competition. In his first real test against a good QB, he failed miserably.

Now, I'm not saying that I'm out on Spears-Jennings. After all, he's a 22-year-old rookie who has shown some impressive flashes this season. At the same time, there was probably a reason he was a seventh-round draft choice with no guarantee of sticking on the roster.

The former Oklahoma Sooners defensive back is excellent when coming downhill, and he uses his speed, long arms, and big hands to his advantage, as he's an impressive tackler. However, the coverage issues we saw from his college film are starting to show up on the NFL stage, and this could be an area of weakness for Pittsburgh's defense if it doesn't improve.

The Steelers were trounced in every facet of the game against the Bengals in Week 10, so the 38-18 blowout loss hardly falls on the shoulders of Robert Spears-Jennings. However, we hope his disappointing outing on Sunday Night Football against Joe Burrow and a talented passing offense was just a one-off and not a sign of things to come.

Add us as a preferred source on Google