The Pittsburgh Steelers are at a crossroads heading into the 2025 off-season. They face a critical decision about improving their offense. With head coach, Mike Tomlin confirmed to stay for the foreseeable future and the quarterback situation still in flux, the team has a lot of work to do to break free from the stagnation that has plagued its offensive unit.
Their immediate future relies heavily on smart talent acquisition, through free agency or the NFL Draft. However, each route presents its own set of challenges and uncertainties.
Free agency offers the allure of proven talent but comes with substantial risks. The Steelers must be extremely discerning when looking at potential veteran players. Given the team’s limited salary cap space, any incoming veteran must have enough juice left from earlier in their career to make a tangible difference.
A player who once had elite production but is now past his prime might still be tempting, but it’s a risky gamble, especially when the Steelers have limited resources to spend. The challenge is finding a player who can still contribute at a high level, without overpaying or investing in someone who won’t significantly move the needle.
READ MORE: 5 potential landing spots for Steelers quarterback Justin Fields in free agency
With free agency, the Steelers must ask themselves, Can this player truly elevate the offense? If the answer is no, the investment is likely not worth it.
Steelers must use Free Agency and the NFL Draft to their advantage
On the other hand, the NFL Draft presents an entirely different set of opportunities—and risks. The Steelers could target younger, hungry prospects, particularly at positions of need such as running back or wide receiver. These players come with a lower price tag, but their inexperience at the NFL level is a key consideration.
While the potential for long-term success exists, so does the possibility of hitting a developmental roadblock. The draft presents uncertainty, but one with a much higher ceiling. If the Steelers can find the right prospect willing to work and prove themselves, they could strike gold and secure a future star at a fraction of the cost of a veteran free agent.
Notes from Gerry Dulac’s piece from Pittsburgh Post Gazette:
— Steelers Network (@SteelersNetwork) January 20, 2025
• Steelers unlikely to bring both Russell Wilson and Justin Fields back (One or other)
• Najee is most likely gone, Warren highly likely to be back
• Team is going big game hunting for a WR in free agency
•…
As the Steelers embark on the off-season, they must weigh the pros and cons of both options. With glaring needs at running back and wide receiver, the team has the chance to make significant strides in fixing their offense. Najee Harris will become a free agent this off-season. Plus, Arthur Smith's offense is still missing an explosive second receiver option.
Whether through a seasoned veteran in free agency or a fresh, promising draft pick, Pittsburgh’s next move will determine the trajectory of their offense for years to come.