In 2024, Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver George Pickens expressed his admiration for Aaron Rodgers, naming the veteran quarterback as his “dream teammate.” This statement resurfaced on social media in February and sparked speculation, as Rodgers is now available following a short and largely disappointing two-year stint with the New York Jets.
For Pickens, playing alongside a quarterback with Rodgers’ pedigree is undoubtedly appealing, especially for a young wide receiver eager to make an impact. However, the reality of such a pairing isn’t as clear-cut for the Steelers, who remain searching for their next long-term quarterback.
Rodgers, a future Hall of Famer with numerous MVPs and a Super Bowl victory under his belt, initially seemed like an ideal candidate to help the Steelers return to contention. During his time with the Jets, he threw for 28 touchdowns but failed to guide the team to more than five wins. It raises questions about his ability to succeed in a new environment.
READ MORE: Recent Aaron Rodgers, Davante Adams trade idea would spell disaster for Steelers
His leadership, once a hallmark of his success in Green Bay, was also under scrutiny, with some reports suggesting friction in the Jets’ locker room. It is a red flag for a Steelers team that values strong leadership both on and off the field, particularly for a team still recovering from the departure of longtime quarterback Ben Roethlisberger.
George Pickens' opinion is not enough to sway the Steelers to make a hasty QB decision.
Despite Pickens’ enthusiasm, it’s clear that the Steelers have reservations. As a second-round pick and a future cornerstone for the franchise, Pickens will have plenty of opportunities to shine. The Steelers cannot afford to make a hasty decision based on one player’s recommendation, especially when the team is facing a crucial off-season.
They are in dire need of a quarterback who can provide stability and leadership, but they must weigh the potential benefits of bringing in Rodgers against the risk of further disrupting team chemistry or investing resources into a player who may not be the answer for the long term.
Aaron Rodgers has undoubtedly demonstrated elite skills during his career, but struggles with the Jets, combined with concerns about his leadership and long-term commitment, make it difficult to envision him as the Steelers’ immediate starter.
While Pickens’ desire to play alongside a future Hall of Famer is understandable, the Steelers must carefully assess all of their options in a pivotal off-season. In the end, they will need more than just a dream teammate to secure their quarterback position for the future.