An identity crisis is no laughing matter. Years of hard work, discipline, and pride can vanish in an instant. Or—in the Pittsburgh Steelers’ case—two seasons. The Steel Curtain moniker that once eloquently described the brand of football in western Pennsylvania has not only lost its shine, but it’s been shattered and swept away.
Now, fans find themselves caught in a nauseating cycle of searching for solutions while simultaneously accepting reality. But at least they aren’t doing it alone.
Week 12's crushing 31–28 defeat to the Chicago Bears wasn’t the Steelers’ first heartbreak of the season—and it likely won’t be the last. Close games are nothing new in Pittsburgh. The franchise has built a reputation on grit, resilience, and surviving ugly battles. But the way they are losing now feels different. It feels like something foundational is cracking.
An unexpected and admirable performance from Mason Rudolph should have been enough to give Pittsburgh a fighting chance against the current rulers of the NFC North. Arthur Smith’s offense battled for four quarters, keeping pace and giving the Steelers life. In return, the unit asked defensive coordinator Teryl Austin’s group for just one stop—one timely answer to swing momentum.
Instead, Caleb Williams carved up the Steelers’ secondary without hesitation. His 239 passing yards and three touchdowns made him look more like a young Peyton Manning than a second-year quarterback still learning the league. And Pittsburgh’s defense, once feared across the NFL, looked closer to a junior varsity squad trying to survive.
The frustration was impossible to hide. Several players expressed disappointment after the game, but none more honestly than linebacker Patrick Queen. He didn’t sugarcoat the performance.
“I think we just have to be better, honestly,” Queen told reporters. And he wasn’t wrong.
Patrick Queen knows the Pittsburgh Steelers defense needs an immediate fix
Pittsburgh allowed 328 total yards on 12 drives, surrendering points in every quarter. It put an enormous strain on a Steelers offense that fought admirably but couldn’t keep pace with Chicago’s consistency.
Then Queen added the part that spoke volumes: “I think sometimes there were schematic issues that we had.”
That statement—calm, direct, and undeniably true—points straight at Teryl Austin. And this isn’t a one-week issue. It’s a pattern. This season, Pittsburgh ranks 28th in yards allowed per game (364.5), a significant jump from last year’s already-unacceptable 334.3. The regression is undeniable, and the consequences are growing louder by the week.
READ MORE: Steelers’ mid-season meltdown has one unexpected upside fans can latch on to
The Steelers’ identity crisis ultimately falls at the feet of Mike Tomlin, but it’s unlikely the organization makes a move at head coach. Tomlin’s rope in Pittsburgh is long. Austin’s is not. If anything, the front office must evaluate his role with urgency. His unit is falling short in nearly every measurable category, and the Steelers are running out of leeway.
Their once firm grip on the AFC North has slipped away, and if the season ended today, they would be on the outside looking in. That’s the harsh cost of a defense that has lost its edge and a coordinator who has lost the room.
A full coaching overhaul isn’t necessary. But something must change—and quickly. Patrick Queen sees the writing on the wall. Fans see it. The numbers scream it. Now it’s up to the Steelers to decide whether they’re willing to fix it before the identity crisis becomes permanent.