For Pittsburgh Steelers fans, last week's Aaron Rodgers announcement may have felt like a championship win. That’s how emotionally taxing and uncertain this offseason has been while the franchise searched for clarity at quarterback.
After months of speculation, frustration, and anticipation, Pittsburgh finally made its move, agreeing to a one-year, $13.65 million deal with four-time All-Pro quarterback Aaron Rodgers.
It’s a calculated risk, but it might pay off historically.
Rodgers, who suffered a torn Achilles just four snaps into the 2023 season with the New York Jets, now finds himself with a fresh opportunity and a historic franchise willing to bet on his comeback story.
For head coach Mike Tomlin and GM Omar Khan, the decision brings in a proven winner and future Hall of Famer for a relatively modest price. For Rodgers, it’s a shot at redemption—and perhaps one final run at a Super Bowl.
Even better? NFL history appears to be on his side.
During a segment on Up and Adams, Kay Adams highlighted how elite quarterbacks have often followed up season-ending injuries with career-defining campaigns. “How about Tom Brady?” Adams asked. He tore his ACL in 2008. Brady returned in 2009 and had a modest season.
But in 2010? He threw 36 touchdowns, just four interceptions, and won his second MVP award.”
Aaron Rodgers can help the Pittsburgh Steelers accomplish MVP-caliber production in 2025
Adams was quick to note that not everyone is Tom Brady, but her next example was just as compelling.
“Let’s talk Peyton Manning,” Adams continued. “He missed all of 2011 with a neck injury. He, too, returned the following year, in 2012, and was solid.
In 2013? He set NFL records for passing yards (5,477) and touchdowns (55) and won MVP.”
Rodgers, like Brady and Manning, is a former MVP and Super Bowl champion. He’s widely regarded as one of the most talented passers in NFL history. And despite missing all but one drive last season, reports suggest Rodgers is healthy, focused, and mentally refreshed.
READ MORE: Experts rethink Steelers' playoff odds after Aaron Rodgers bombshell
The parallels are hard to ignore. Like Manning in Denver and Brady in Tampa Bay, Rodgers joins a team with a strong defense, solid coaching, and hungry fans. Pittsburgh may not have a loaded offense, but they have a system and culture built for success, and Rodgers has the experience to elevate it.
The Steelers didn’t just sign a quarterback. They signed a symbol of belief—that greatness can be reborn.
Rodgers may not be guaranteed to repeat history, but history has paved the path. If he follows the trajectory of legends before him, the 2025 season could be one to remember for the black and gold.
He's not Brady or Manning—but if Aaron Rodgers is anywhere near his former self, Pittsburgh might have struck gold.