We knew how much was riding on this Week 10 AFC North matchup between the Pittsburgh Steelers and the Cincinnati Bengals, which makes this sting all the more because Mike McCarthy's team was humiliated on Sunday Night Football against the biggest threat in their division.
With the loss, the Bengals advance to 7-2, while the Steelers fall to 6-3. With eight games still remaining on the schedule, Pittsburgh is just one game back from first place in the division.
So what's the big deal, right?
This game had seismic divisional implications—and we could see this coming a mile away as the Steelers went back to the drawing board during their Week 9 bye. Unfortunately, the tide shifted in a catastrophic way, and with the 38-18 loss on SNF (that was somehow never even as close as it looked), Pittsburgh may have already pulverized their chances of an AFC North crown this year.
The Pittsburgh Steelers' chances of winning the AFC North plummeted after Week 10
Heading into the Steelers-Bengals game on Sunday Night Football, McCarthy's team was given a respectable 38% chance of winning the AFC North, per The Athletic's playoff projections. With a win, these odds would have skyrocketed to 66%.
Unfortunately, the loss buried Pittsburgh's title dreams.
After losing to the Bengals in Week 10, the Steelers' chances of claiming the AFC North crown dropped from 38% to just 11%. It's not hard to understand why.
The Bengals not only hold a competitive edge over the Steelers after their latest win, but they also have an easier schedule down the stretch. While Pittsburgh still has upcoming games against the Denver Broncos and Jacksonville Jaguars, Cincinnati gets arguably the easiest remaining slate in the NFL, as they will face the Commanders, Saints, Browns, Chiefs, Panthers, Colts, Ravens, and Browns again.
And of that group, their December 13 contest against Kansas City looks like the only opponent that will give them a run for their money.
Not only that, but the Bengals have a better divisional record than the Steelers entering Week 11 (2-1 compared to 1-2). It's unlikely they will slip up against the Browns and Ravens. Because they split their head-to-head matchups, the divisional record comes next in a tiebreaker.
If Cincy stays ahead of Pittsburgh in the divisional win column, the Steelers would have to finish with a record better than the Bengals to claim the AFC North crown. So, for example, if Joe Burrow and the Bengals reach 12 wins this year, the Steelers would need 13 wins (or 12 plus one fewer loss because of a tie somewhere along the way) to claim the division title and host a playoff game.
But there's another factor that we don't want to discuss: the Bengals are simply a better team than the Steelers. They have a better quarterback, better receivers, and they are playing better on both sides of the ball over the past month of the season.
The Steelers are fortunate to still have great chances of making the AFC playoffs
While their odds of winning the division are suddenly as grim as we could have imagined, the Steelers still have a surprisingly great chance of making the AFC playoffs.
Because the New England Patriots are falling apart and the Browns just buried the Texans in Week 10—who are now 3-6—the competition for Wild Card seeding in the AFC is very slim.
Oddsmakers know this, and based on The Athletic's playoff projections, the Steelers still have an 80% chance of being one of the seven AFC teams in the postseason this year. Sadly, this is more by default and a lack of serious competition than by their own doing.
If the season ended ahead of Week 11, the Steelers would be the 6th seed, traveling to Kansas City for a road game in the Wild Card round. The Broncos would be the 5th seed, and the Browns would be the 7th seed.
Because of the latest injury to quarterback Drake Maye, the Patriots may be a team that the Steelers no longer need to worry about. Same goes for the Texans, who can really only afford one loss the rest of the way to give themselves a shot at cracking the postseason.
Unfortunately, there's a massive difference between cashing a ticket into the playoffs and actually earning a division title and hosting postseason games.
The Pittsburgh Steelers still have a shot at an AFC North title this year, but it's easy to see why they have just an 11% chance to earn the divisional crown.
