The NFL coaching cycle is in full rotation, and for the Pittsburgh Steelers, the dust has finally settled—at least at the top. Omar Khan and Art Rooney II made a joint decision to hire Mike McCarthy as the fourth head coach in franchise history, a move that felt safe, calculated, and undeniably Steelers-like. After the emotional close of the Mike Tomlin era, stability mattered. McCarthy provides exactly that.
But stability wasn’t what many fans were craving.
The calls to move on from Tomlin weren’t rooted in impatience. They were fueled by exhaustion. Inconsistent results masked by winning regular seasons had become nauseating, especially when January arrived, and answers never followed. Many fans were ready to endure the pain of starting from scratch if it meant handing the reins to a young, offensive-minded coach like Nathan Scheelhaase. Instead, Pittsburgh responded with experience over experimentation. Better luck next time.
So yes, McCarthy’s hiring landed with mixed emotions. It’s not shocking—just slightly deflating for those hoping for a full-scale reset. McCarthy is a traditional leader, a Super Bowl winner, and an 18-year NFL head coaching veteran. He brings credibility and structure. What he doesn’t bring is the fresh offensive spark many believed this franchise desperately needed.
That’s where the door may still be open.
Despite McCarthy already in place, the Steelers still have a legitimate chance to bring Schalhaase into the building as part of the new staff. And honestly, it might be the perfect compromise.
The Pitsburgh Steeers must convince Nathan Scheelhaase to become the new offensive coordinator
Scheelhaase was a key figure behind the Los Angeles Rams’ explosive offense this past season. As the pass game coordinator, he worked side by side with Sean McVay, helping craft an attack that overwhelmed defenses weekly. The results speak loudly. The Rams ranked first in points per game (30), yards per game (397), and touchdowns per game (3.7). That isn’t just talent—it’s design, creativity, and adaptability.
McCarthy is an offensive mind in his own right, but replicating those numbers isn’t realistic without innovation. And innovation is exactly what Scheelhaase represents. Offering him the offensive coordinator role in Pittsburgh would be a win for everyone involved.
For the Steelers, it would mean pairing an established head coach with a modern offensive architect. Experience meets evolution. Leadership meets imagination. It would signal that Pittsburgh isn’t clinging to the past—it’s blending it with the future. For Scheelhaase, it’s a massive opportunity. A promotion. A national stage. A chance to prove he’s more than a rising name and instead a foundational piece of a franchise searching for answers.
READ MORE: Steelers gave Mike McCarthy one massive job right out of the gate
This wouldn’t be settling. It would be smart.
McCarthy doesn’t need to be the only voice shaping the offense. In fact, empowering a younger coordinator could extend his effectiveness and fast-track Pittsburgh’s long-overdue offensive identity shift. The Steelers don’t need to choose between old-school leadership and new-age creativity—they can have both.
Hopefully, Khan and Rooney II see the same vision. Convincing Scheelhaase to wear the Black and Gold wouldn’t erase the disappointment felt by some fans—but it would soften it. More importantly, it could accelerate Pittsburgh’s return to relevance where it matters most.
Sometimes the best moves aren’t the loudest. They’re the ones that quietly change everything. This feels like one of those moments—a potential match made in football heaven.