Skip to main content

Steelers are finally realizing fans were right about Aaron Rodgers all along

ByTommy Jaggi
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers
Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

During the 2025 offseason, Pittsburgh Steelers fans knew that Aaron Rodgers was not a good enough quarterback to string them along until they finally decided to sign a one-year contract in June. Though the Steelers made the playoffs, they were trounced 30-6 by the Houston Texans in one of the worst performances of Rodgers' career.

Steelers general manager Omar Khan and team president saw what we all saw last year and decided to run it back anyway.

This season, Rodgers has been even worse. But his deplorable performance against the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday Night Football in Week 10 finally showed the Steelers what the fans knew all along: Rodgers isn't close to good enough to get the job done against good teams.

Aaron Rodgers showed again against the Bengals why he's not enough for the Pittsburgh Steelers

Before Rodgers completed his first pass on SNF, Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow had 245 passing yards (that's not a typo). This is obviously a horrible look for Pittsburgh's defense, and they deserve plenty of blame. But it showed just how awful Rodgers was in this contest.

Through the first three quarters of the game, the Steelers were down 31-3. This was enough for the Bengals to take their foot off the gas just enough for Rodgers to throw two touchdown passes in the fourth quarter, finishing 15 of 29 for 143 yards (4.9 yards per attempt) and two touchdowns (but just a 26.4 QBR).

However, before garbage-time action in the final quarter, Rodgers was just 4 of 14 for a mere 27 yards with zero touchdowns (and a dropped pick by a Cincinnati defender on a pass to Darnell Washington).

Had Rodgers been pulled from the contest after three quarters and Mike McCarthy hadn't allowed him to pad the stats, he would have finished Week 10 with a despicable 39.5 passer rating in arguably the worst quarterback performance of the 2026 NFL season.

Rodgers simply doesn't have it anymore. Yes, his receivers are a problem, the route concepts are dull at times, and the defense did nothing to aid the offense in this contest. But at the end of the day, a respectable quarterback needs to rise above and show the ability to move the chains.

And it's not like the Bengals even had a good defense. Before Week 10, Cincinnati's defense ranked in the bottom half of the league. Two weeks ago, they surrendered 36 points and 440 offensive yards to the now 1-7 Tennessee Titans.

The Steelers' contending aspirations came crashing back down to earth, and the more Aaron Rodgers shows his true colors as the player he really is these days, the less hope fans have for Pittsburgh going anywhere in the postseason this year.

Add us as a preferred source on Google