The Pittsburgh Steelers are in a weird spot. They're trying to find their quarterback of the future while also expressing interest in bringing back Aaron Rodgers for his age-43 campaign.
Enter the Indianapolis Colts' Anthony Richardson, who's reportedly been permitted to seek a trade amid his uncertain outlook with the club (h/t ESPN's Stephen Holder). The 2023 No. 4 overall pick's transition to the NFL hasn't been smooth, to say the least. However, a change of scenery could prove fruitful for anyone willing to take a chance on him; why shouldn't it be the Steelers?
Yes, Richardson's elite combination of arm strength, size, and mobility has been more of an idea than a reality through three seasons as a pro. But the upside is undeniable and tantalizing, and Pittsburgh has multiple reasons to take a flier on him as a reclamation project.
A Pittsburgh Steelers trade for Colts QB Anthony Richardson makes too much sense
This is the type of calculated risk worth taking for the Steelers. Recent history tells us it won't take more than a mid-to-late-round selection to acquire Richardson from the Colts. He has the potential to establish himself as Pittsburgh's long-term solution under center, which can't be said about many (if any) other possible targets.
Meanwhile, there's virtually no downside to Richardson failing spectacularly, assuming his $23.5 million fifth-year option isn't exercised. The Steelers can move on from him after 2026 with no strings attached in this scenario. And perhaps more notably, Pittsburgh would almost assuredly be picking at or near the top of the 2027 draft if he flops.
Part of why the Steelers are open to Rodgers returning is that it buys them more time to address their signal-caller issues. Well, Richardson can fill that same role while giving them someone to evaluate in-house.
We know what Rodgers is at this stage of his illustrious career. The four-time MVP gives the Steelers a viable stopgap and helps continue their ride on the treadmill of mediocrity. Nevertheless, Richardson can help them return to prominence regardless of whether he sinks or swims.
Richardson doesn't turn 24 until May and was a highly touted prospect not long ago. He was 6-5 in 11 games as a starter in 2024 despite posting a negative passing touchdown-to-interception ratio (eight to 12), thriving as a runner. The Colts leaned on his legs to the tune of 499 rushing yards and six scores, giving the Steelers proof of concept.