Skip to main content

Steelers may need to copy Vikings' tough-love approach with DK Metcalf

ByAllison Koehler
Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf
Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver DK Metcalf | Joe Sargent/GettyImages

The Pittsburgh Steelers might need to bench DK Metcalf for a game, and the Minnesota Vikings just showed them why that might not be such a crazy idea.

There's no sugar-coating it. Metcalf has been downright awful for much of the 2026 season. Through nine games, he has just 35 receptions for 432 yards and two touchdowns. He's caught only about half the passes thrown his way, and the drops, penalties, and disappearing acts are getting old.

Former Steelers offensive lineman Trai Essex has already called for Metcalf to ride the bench. And after watching Pittsburgh's latest offensive disaster against Cincinnati, we can't blame him.

Pittsburgh Steelers should take a page from the Minnesota Vikings with DK Metcalf

The Vikings recently made rookie defensive lineman Caleb Banks, their first-round pick in April, a healthy scratch against the Buffalo Bills.

That's a pretty bold move for a guy selected 18th overall.

But look what happened next. Banks returned against the Green Bay Packers, made his first career start, and earned an 82.2 overall grade from Pro Football Focus. It was easily his best performance of the season.

Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores said competition and accountability played into the decision, according to The Viking Age.

I'm not saying sitting Banks automatically turned him into a better player. But the Vikings weren't afraid to make a tough decision, and their rookie came back playing better football.

Why can't Pittsburgh try something similar?

Metcalf isn't some young receiver still learning the ropes. He's a veteran on a massive five-year, $150 million deal, with a $33 million average annual value in new money.

Nobody expects perfection for that kind of investment. But 48 receiving yards per game? Come on.

The Steelers didn't bring Metcalf to Pittsburgh to watch him struggle with routine catches while Aaron Rodgers keeps forcing passes in his direction.

A week on the bench might be exactly what gets him going again. Maybe he comes back with his hair on fire and starts looking like the receiver Pittsburgh thought it was getting. It's not like Metcalf can do any worse.

Unfortunately, Aaron Rodgers and Mike McCarthy are stubborn as mules, especially the quarterback. They've continued backing Metcalf despite his struggles, so I wouldn't hold my breath waiting for either of them to pull the plug.

There's also the issue of who replaces him.

Michael Pittman Jr. and Roman Wilson have returned to practice, but neither has been activated from injured reserve. Rookie Germie Bernard has shown promise, although asking him to carry the receiving corps isn't exactly fair.

The sooner Pittman and Wilson return, the fewer excuses McCarthy will have for sticking with Metcalf, so it's worth following Pittsburgh's roster developments closely.

Benching Metcalf wouldn't magically fix this offense. His size and deep-ball ability still give defenses something to think about, even when he's struggling.

But once Pittman and Wilson are ready, McCarthy could finally afford to experiment with a different receiver combination. Giving Bernard more opportunities while letting Metcalf watch for a week might reveal whether Pittsburgh's passing game actually functions better without forcing the ball to its biggest name.

Add us as a preferred source on Google