Pro Bowler's unexpected performance slump gives Steelers huge advantage in trade market

The Pittsburgh Steelers’ defense, once known for its physicality and relentless nature, suffered an embarrassing defeat in the Wild Card round of the NFL playoffs at the hands of the Baltimore Ravens. The Steelers gave up 299 rushing yards to Ravens running back Derrick Henry, a performance that exuded significant deviation from the team’s traditional defensive identity.

Among the most glaring images from the game was Henry’s brutal stiff-arm on Pittsburgh’s All-Pro safety, Minkah Fitzpatrick, a visual that captured just how outmatched the Steelers were on the field that night. For Fitzpatrick, a player who had once been a cornerstone of the defense, the defeat signified a rough playoff exit and a noticeable decline in his performance.

Fitzpatrick’s journey with the Steelers has been a story of promise and success, having earned multiple All-Pro selections since his acquisition from the Miami Dolphins in 2019. His impact on the Steelers’ secondary was immediate, and his knack for turnovers helped the team regain a defensive edge.

In 2022, he recorded six interceptions—a career-high, showcasing his playmaking ability. However, since then, Fitzpatrick’s production has dropped dramatically. In the last two seasons, he has recorded just one interception, the lowest total of his career. His reduced impact on the field and the defense’s struggles raised questions about his future with the team.

Steelers must decide if Minkah Fitzpatrick is a part of their rebuild

As the Steelers face the reality of rebuilding their roster to contend with the top teams in the AFC, the decline of their star safety could lead to some tough decisions. The franchise has historically held onto its key players, especially those who contribute to the team’s defensive identity.

READ MORE: Quinn Ewers' NFL Draft declaration does nothing for QB-desperate Steelers

This playoff loss to the Ravens may prompt a reevaluation of that approach. Parting ways with Fitzpatrick might seem like a drastic move, but if the Steelers believe his decline is not a one-off, it could be in the best to explore trade options.

The Steelers could shop Fitzpatrick to acquire valuable draft capital or players that fit their evolving image, particularly as the team transitions into a new phase under head coach Mike Tomlin. The defensive scheme could be retooled, and moving on from an aging safety may free up resources for other areas of need.

While Fitzpatrick’s future with Pittsburgh remains uncertain, his performance in 2024 will likely be a major factor in whether he remains a staple of the Steelers’ defense or is sent elsewhere to find a fresh start.