The Pittsburgh Steelers had a prime opportunity to bounce back this week after a horrendous performance in Week 10's loss against the Cincinnati Bengals, but they managed to squander it completely. The Philadelphia Eagles reminded the NFL world that even the most disappointing teams are capable of pulling off an upset, as they defeated the Steelers 19-16.
While I have to give credit to Philly for playing a strong game, this loss was more about the Steelers' ineptitude on offense than anything else. They failed to cross the 100-yard mark as a unit in the first half for the second straight week, and quarterback Aaron Rodgers was outplayed by Joe Milton in just his second career start.
The defense kept them in the game long enough for a comeback attempt, but it ultimately fell short. Now sitting at 6-4, the only thing keeping Pittsburgh firmly in playoff contention is the rest of the AFC's struggles. Here are the biggest takeaways from the Steelers' second loss in a row.
Aaron Rodgers' struggles, DK Metcalf ejection highlight biggest Pittsburgh Steelers takeaways
Aaron Rodgers is not a playoff-caliber QB
There is no way to sugarcoat it: Rodgers wasn't nearly good enough to win this game. He once again failed to push the ball past 10 yards, something that has plagued him for the majority of his career with the Steelers. He completed 17 of 20 passes in the first half, but for just 95 yards. It didn't really get better in the second half, even as he tried to complete the comeback, finishing with 227 yards on 44 pass attempts.
You can blame the receivers, the playcalling, or Rodgers himself. They all have contributed to the struggles in the passing game. One thing that has become painfully obvious, however, is that the Steelers' QB is not playing well enough for them to be a threat in the playoffs. Unless that changes over the next seven games, nothing else they do will matter.
The DK Metcalf situation has officially has officially jumped the shark
Over the past week, several of us at Still Curtain made the case for DK Metcalf to be benched. Tommy Jaggi and Allison Kohler both wrote pieces explaining their rationale behind the idea, and I spoke about it on our Still Curtain Podcast. It really had gotten that bad, but it somehow got even worse against the Eagles.
Not only did Metcalf catch just one of his four targets for two yards, but he was ejected from the game due to two separate personal foul penalties. If it wasn't clear to the coaching staff and front office before this week that Metcalf needs to go, it better be now. Not only has he been a net negative on the field, but now he can't even keep his cool. It's time for this relationship to end as soon as possible.
Steelers' offensive line sorely missed Mason McCormick
It didn't take long for the loss of starting left guard Mason McCormick to cause issues for the Steelers' offense. Not only did the run game fail to get going to start the game, but McCormick's replacement, Spencer Anderson, gave up a sack early in the second quarter. Things spiraled from there, with the line giving up a combined five sacks and generating very little push in the run game.
It was already obvious earlier this season when Anderson was starting that he lacks the consistency to be a full-time player, but he was especially terrible in this game. Assuming he is fully healthy and up to speed, it's time to see what rookie Gennings Dunker can do in Week 12.
Steelers pass rush goes quiet without Nick Herbig and Alex Highsmith
The Steelers managed three sacks in this game, but only one of them was a dominant rep. Alex Highsmith beat Eagles star left tackle Jordan Mailata cleanly for a strip sack early in the game, but the offense recovered the fumble. After that, Pittsburgh mostly failed to generate any consistent pressure against Philadelphia.
The Steelers entered the game without Nick Herbig, then lost Highsmith to an ankle injury. Losing both of them was too much to overcome, and it allowed Milton to get comfortable as the game dragged on. Unless they get both of them back sooner rather than later, fans should expect to see more of the same.
Steelers are barreling towards another first-round playoff exit
This one is not just about the Steelers' performance this week, but no game they have played so far this season better illustrates this point than this one. Even on the road, and even in a specific location that they haven't won in since 1965, this game simply couldn't be a loss if Pittsburgh wanted to be taken seriously as a threat in the playoffs.
The Eagles had lost seven consecutive games coming into this week, many of which were against teams that are objectively worse than the Steelers. They were down to their third QB, had been relying on multiple unproven players in both trenches, and hadn't kept a game within seven points since Jalen Hurts last played.
If the Steelers couldn't end their decades of futility playing in Philadelphia against this version of the Eagles, they may never win there again. It also makes winning a playoff game this season for the first time in 10 years feel like a pipe dream.
