When the Pittsburgh Steelers traded with the Seattle Seahawks for DK Metcalf during the 2025 offseason, it would have been unthinkable to consider benching him just a year and a half into his Steelers career.
But as we sit here entering Week 11, this may honestly be the next logical step.
Nobody should be above reproach—especially not Metcalf, given how he's played this season. Before padding his stats with two receptions and a touchdown in fourth-quarter garbage time against the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday Night Football in Week 10, Metcalf had zero receptions on four targets, and the Steelers, as a team, had just 27 receiving yards through the first three quarters.
In his first nine games, Metcalf has recorded just 35 receptions on 70 targets for 432 yards and two touchdowns. If you prorate his production over a 17-game season, Metcalf is on track to earn just 66 receptions on 132 targets for 816 yards and four touchdowns—making him one of the least efficient receivers in the league.
And to give you an idea of just how bad that is, let's use a Steelers example from a few years back. In 2019, James Washington—who hasn't been able to find a job in the NFL for four years now—earned 735 yards and three touchdowns on just 80 targets (15 games) in 2019... and that was with Mason Rudolph and Devlin 'Duck' Hodges throwing him the football.
Now it's long past time to have a painful conversation about why Metcalf may need to watch from the sidelines—at least for the time being.
DK Metcalf is one of the least efficient wide receivers in the NFL in 2026
More than halfway through the 2026 season, Metcalf has been one of the least reliable and least consistent receivers in football.
Despite ranking 20th in market share (23.57%), Metcalf is 113th in yards after the catch per reception (3.4) among qualifying pass-catchers with at least 15 targets. Rodgers also has a collection of drops (though he's only been credited with four from Pro Football Reference, and his 73.0 targeted passer rating ranks 163rd in the NFL.
It gets worse. Metcalf ranks 133rd in yards per target (6.2), 173rd in catch percentage (50.0%), and 131st in success rate (40.0%).
Not only has Metcalf not come close to resembling a WR1, but he's not even as efficient as nearly every WR2 in the league in 2026. And because of his egregious struggles, the Steelers can't keep sitting on their hands.
The Pittsburgh Steelers should bench DK Metcalf (at least temporarily) despite heavy investment
At some point, your former reputation doesn't matter if you're not producing results on the field. Neither should the investment matter. Though the Steelers paid a second-round pick in the trade and handed him a $132 million contract extension, head coach Mike McCarthy can't let general manager Omar Khan's heavy investment leave the offense hamstrung.
Instead, the Steelers need to see what else they have and if they can get it to work. With Roman Wilson trending in the right direction and getting closer to seeing the field, perhaps McCarthy should see what a pairing of Wilson and Germie Bernard would look like. Both receivers run better routes than Metcalf, and neither has worse hands.
In the meantime, Pittsburgh could give tight ends Pat Freiermuth and Darnell Washington more opportunity in the passing game while descreasing Metcalf'f role.
When Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers attempt to force-feed Metcalf and run the passing offense through the inconsistent receiver, it never goes well. Perhaps demoting Metcalf is the only way to reignite his career at this point.
If DK Metcalf's name were Brandon Smith or Brandon Johnson, would he still have a role in the starting lineup at this point? If the Steelers didn't trade a king's ransom to acquire him, would they have already given up on Metcalf at this point?
These are fair questions. I know if this team is to have postseason success this year, Metcalf will likely need to be involved in some way, shape, or form. But considering how bad he's played all year, perhaps the next logical step is to demote him for the time being and see what the offense looks like when he's not on the field.
