Aaron Rodgers' praise for Steelers' makes lack of decision more confusing

What is holding back a seemingly perfect union?
Miami Dolphins v New York Jets
Miami Dolphins v New York Jets | Luke Hales/GettyImages

Aaron Rodgers isn’t shy about speaking his mind. On Tuesday morning, he gave NFL fans and insiders plenty to dissect during his appearance on The Pat McAfee Show. Among the key takeaways was a clear acknowledgment of his recent visits and conversations with several NFL teams — including the Pittsburgh Steelers.

In March, the Steelers hosted Rodgers for a reported six-hour meeting, hoping to clarify his intentions and possibly solidify a deal to make the veteran quarterback their starter for the 2025 season. Despite the length and depth of the visit, no agreement has been reached. Less than a week before the NFL Draft, the lack of progress raises concerns.

READ MORE: Aaron Rodgers strikes Steelers with reality check at the worst possible time

Rodgers stated that money is not the deciding factor in his return. “I told everyone — one of the teams I talked to — it isn’t about the money,” Rodgers said during the interview. “I’ll play for 10 [million].” It was a jaw-dropping statement, not because of the number, but because of the message: he’s only coming back on his terms. Those terms extend far beyond the paycheck.

Rodgers was also generous in his praise of the Steelers organization. He highlighted his admiration for Head Coach Mike Tomlin, stating, “Obviously, I went out to Pittsburgh and I have a lot of respect for Mike Tomlin.” He followed that up with kind words for new offensive coordinator Arthur Smith, adding, “I’m a big fan of Arthur Smith and I like what he’s all about.”

Aaron Rodgers is not satiffied with the current state of the Pittsburgh Steelers

Yet, for all the kind words, respect, and alleged willingness to play for pennies, the most glaring detail remains: Rodgers is still not a Steeler. And that could be the clearest signal yet that Pittsburgh is not his final destination.

The hesitation — whether on Rodgers’ side or the Steelers’ — speaks volumes. The Steelers, desperate for quarterback stability, would jump at the opportunity to pair their veteran roster with a four-time MVP. But Rodgers comes with complexities: health concerns, age, off-field interests, and an uncertain timeline for commitment.

With the 2025 NFL Draft just days away, the Steelers can no longer afford to live in limbo. They’ve shown heavy interest in prospects like Shedeur Sanders, Jaxson Dart, and Kyle McCord — all of whom could be available depending on how the board falls. The need to secure a future quarterback has become more urgent than ever.

Rodgers may not be demanding big money, but his indecision is costing Pittsburgh valuable time. The Steelers need clarity and commitment. Right now, Aaron Rodgers doesn’t seem ready to offer either. While the connection between Rodgers and the Steelers was intriguing, all signs point to Pittsburgh turning the page and preparing to draft their future — not rent it.

More Steelers News and Analysis

Schedule