Steelers' biggest draft steal will make top fantasy analyst eat his words

Matthew Berry just gave on Steelers draft pick all the motivation he needs.
Kaleb Johnson RB Iowa Hawkeyes
Kaleb Johnson RB Iowa Hawkeyes | Stacy Revere/GettyImages

Just a few days was all it took for Kaleb Johnson, the Pittsburgh Steelers’ third-round pick and No. 83 overall selection, to receive his first big snub in the NFL. Less than a week after hearing his name called at the 2025 NFL Draft, fantasy football expert Matthew Berry released his top-10 dynasty rookie rankings and left Johnson off the list entirely.

Seriously? What's not to like?

Johnson, the former Iowa star who rushed for 1,537 yards and 21 touchdowns last season, didn’t even crack the rankings. Meanwhile, Ashton Jeanty, Omarion Hampton, and Quinshon Judkins received glowing projections and fantasy love. They’re talented, admittedly, but Johnson belongs in that conversation.

Let’s be honest: Johnson has every tool to succeed, especially in Pittsburgh. He’s a patient, physical zone runner with great vision and toughness—exactly what Mike Tomlin’s offense thrives on. He’s not just a power back, though. Johnson brings long speed, the ability to slip tackles, and a nose for the endzone. This could go a long way in shaping his fantasy football value in dynasty leagues.

The Pittsburgh Steelers will treat Kaleb Johnson like a dynasty stud by Year 2

Since 2021, Harris has been the workhorse for the Steelers, consistently hitting 1,000 yards despite shaky quarterback play. With uncertainty under center, the Steelers will rely more on skill players.

Johnson fits like a glove.

Watching Johnson run reminds me of a young Le'Veon Bell. He’s deliberate, finishes runs with authority, and does not dance behind the line. More importantly, he plays with a chip on his shoulder. Getting snubbed like this? It’s only going to fuel him more.

I get that fantasy analysts have to project long-term upside, but ignoring Johnson’s situation and talent feels lazy. He’s walking into a system that leans on the run, and he has a very real chance to earn immediate touches. He doesn’t need to sit and learn—he’s ready now.

READ MORE: Steelers rookies face high stakes after first 2025 performance projections

If he puts up even 75 percent of what he did at Iowa, he’ll be one of the most efficient rookie backs in fantasy this year.

I respect Matthew Berry, but this call? He missed. Kaleb Johnson is the kind of back who sneaks into the third round and then leads fantasy teams to playoff runs. Come December, don’t be surprised when Johnson’s name is being spoken with the same reverence as the ones who made Berry’s list.

Fantasy managers: don’t make the same mistake.

More Steelers News and Analysis

Schedule