Egregious penalties in Week 2 sabotage stat line of Steelers' biggest X-Factor

In the Pittsburgh Steelers' Week 2 matchup against the Denver Broncos, wide receiver George Pickens proved to be the X-Factor, showcasing the game-changing potential he brings to the offense. Although his official stat line — two receptions for 29 yards on four targets — may seem underwhelming, it doesn’t fully capture his impact on the game.

Unfortunately, two of Pickens' biggest plays, a highlight reel 51-yard reception and an athletic touchdown catch, were erased due to offensive penalties.

Pickens’ ability to stretch the field was evident on those two negated plays. His 51-yard reception demonstrated his explosiveness, while his athletic touchdown showcased his elite body control and catching radius. These plays, though wiped out, highlighted Pickens as a threat the Broncos defense had to respect.

Pickens' presence alone altered the defensive scheme, opening up opportunities for the Steelers' run game and short passing attack.

Steelers offense lives and dies by George Pickens' production

Grading the primary wideouts' performance a "C" acknowledges both his contributions and the limitations placed on him by the circumstances. The penalties were out of his control, but they directly impacted how his day would reflect on the stat sheet.

In the moments where he contributed, Pickens was efficient, catching two of his four targets for 29 yards. Defenders struggled to stay in front of him - holding the WR to stand a chance. However, outside of the erased opportunities, Pickens' role was limited by the flow of the game and the Steelers’ overall offensive struggles. He showed up, became a decoy and his major plays were blemishes.

As the Steelers' top receiver, Pickens carries a responsibility to consistently make himself available, just like the all-time greats at the position. While he has all the physical tools — speed, strength, and the ability to make contested catches — he’ll need to unleash his potential as the season progresses.

Being a number-one receiver means constantly finding ways to be a reliable target, regardless of what the defense throws at you. The glimpses of brilliance are apparent, but Pickens must string together consistent performances, avoiding quiet games and fully capitalizing on his opportunities.

Pickens has the potential to be a true game-breaker for the Steelers, and if he can refine his craft and eliminate quiet outings, the sky is the limit for his 2024 campaign. We can see Arthur Smith's offense is improving weekly. The rate may feel slow-paced, but it's the second week of the NFL season.

The offense has a new offensive coordinator and quarterback. It'll take time for things to gel. Primetime receivers become catalysts for offenses. George Pickens shows signs of greatness, and I expect to see it soon.