Questionable QB plan puts Steelers in unfavorable Kyler Murray bidding war

The Steelers cannot afford to sit back on this negotiation.
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray
Arizona Cardinals quarterback Kyler Murray | Joe Camporeale-Imagn Images

The NFL’s free agency tampering period always delivers chaos. Deals are discussed before the ink can dry, trade rumors fly across timelines, and front offices work overtime trying to position their teams for the future. Through all the noise, the Pittsburgh Steelers have managed to quietly place themselves in an intriguing position—especially at quarterback.

For the moment, Pittsburgh still finds itself without a clear starting signal caller. But that situation could change soon with the anticipated release of Kyler Murray from the Arizona Cardinals. After nine seasons, Murray’s tenure there appears to be reaching its natural conclusion, and when he officially hits the open market, the Steelers are reportedly one of the two teams he is seriously considering.

For a franchise that entered the offseason needing clarity at the most important position in football, that possibility alone should generate excitement.

Murray’s time in Arizona produced plenty of highlights. Since entering the league as the No. 1 overall pick in 2019, he has accumulated 20,460 passing yards and thrown 121 touchdowns. Along the way, he earned two Pro Bowl selections and established himself as one of the league’s most dynamic dual-threat quarterbacks.

His mobility is what truly separates him. Few quarterbacks force defenses to adjust the way Murray does. His ability to extend plays outside the pocket and punish defenders with his legs creates opportunities that traditional pocket passers simply cannot replicate. For offensive play callers, that type of athleticism unlocks a deeper playbook and a level of unpredictability that keeps defenses guessing.

Still, Murray’s résumé is not without blemishes.

Despite the impressive numbers, his time in Arizona never produced a playoff victory. For some franchises, that would raise serious concerns. Yet the reality of this current free agent quarterback market is simple—no available option arrives without questions attached.

Pittsburgh could revisit familiar names such as Russell Wilson or Aaron Rodgers. Both veterans have accomplished careers and championship experience. But if the Steelers are truly thinking about the future instead of the past, Murray represents a far more intriguing direction.

The Pittsburgh Steelers must win the Kyler Murray bid against the Minnesota Vikings

Financially, the situation could also work in Pittsburgh’s favor. With Arizona expected to absorb roughly $54.7 million in dead cap by releasing him, Murray may become available at a surprisingly reasonable price. That scenario would give Steelers general manager Omar Khan the flexibility to approach negotiations creatively rather than committing overwhelming resources to a single player.

That flexibility matters for a team still building around a deep pool of draft capital and emerging talent.

From a strategic standpoint, signing Murray would represent a calculated gamble—but one that carries significant upside. If he struggles or fails to meet expectations, Pittsburgh still has multiple paths forward, whether that involves developing Will Howard or addressing the position again through the draft in future seasons.

But if Murray thrives in Pittsburgh’s system, the reward could be enormous. The Steelers would suddenly possess a franchise quarterback capable of leading the team for years to come.

That is a gamble worth considering.

The only complication is competition. The Minnesota Vikings are also reportedly pursuing Murray, and their roster presents an attractive environment. Star wide receiver Justin Jefferson alone is the kind of weapon that can influence a quarterback’s decision.

Yet Pittsburgh offers something equally compelling: stability, tradition, and a clear path toward competing in the postseason.

Ultimately, the decision will belong to Murray. But if the Steelers truly believe he can unlock their offense and reshape their future, Khan must now do what great general managers do best—make the vision convincing enough that the player wants to be part of it.

Because sometimes, the biggest moves in the offseason are the ones that begin with a single leap of faith.

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations