Skip to main content

Steelers' brutal Bengals loss puts Mike McCarthy's bye-week decision under scrutiny

ByAllison Koehler
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike McCarthy
Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike McCarthy | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Pittsburgh Steelers had two weeks to get ready for the Cincinnati Bengals, and somehow Mike McCarthy's team looked less prepared than it has all season. Sunday's embarrassing 38-18 loss was bad enough on its own, but coming out of a bye week looking that lost? That's where things get really frustrating.

McCarthy gave his players the entire Week 9 bye off, which was a big change from how Mike Tomlin handled things. Tomlin typically brought players in for a couple of practices before giving them four days off. McCarthy skipped that part and sent everyone home for the week, something he was known for in Green Bay and Dallas.

At the time, it wasn't a crazy decision. Pittsburgh had just won four straight games and was coming off a demanding stretch that included a trip to Paris. But after watching the Bengals damage Pittsburgh's AFC North hopes, it's fair to wonder whether McCarthy gave his team a little too much time off.

Pittsburgh Steelers looked anything but prepared after Mike McCarthy's bye-week decision

McCarthy actually has a pretty good history coming out of bye weeks. His teams went 12-6 in those games during his previous 18 seasons as a head coach.

And nobody's suggesting two more practices would've magically shut down Joe Burrow and Ja'Marr Chase.

But come on. The Steelers had an extra week to figure out how to slow Cincinnati's offense, and they still got absolutely shredded.

Burrow completed 35 of 44 passes for 409 yards and four touchdowns. Chase went off for 231 receiving yards, and Pittsburgh's pass rush managed just one sack.

Defensive coordinator Patrick Graham had plenty of time to come up with a plan for Cincinnati's passing attack. Whatever that plan was, it sure didn't work.

The offense wasn't much better.

Aaron Rodgers couldn't get anything going, and the Steelers managed just three points in the first half. Pittsburgh finished with just 222 total yards, while Cincinnati piled up 484.

McCarthy's offense had been leaning on its running game during the winning streak, but that identity practically disappeared against Cincinnati. Once the Bengals built their lead, Rodgers was stuck trying to throw Pittsburgh back into the game.

The Steelers' miserable offensive showing was frustrating enough. Watching the defense get picked apart after two weeks of preparation made it even worse.

McCarthy shouldn't get buried just because he gave his players a break. Rest is critical, especially this late in the season. But when you make that decision and your team comes out looking completely overmatched, you're gonna hear about it.

The Bengals weren't exactly sitting around waiting for Pittsburgh, either. They came into Sunday riding a four-game winning streak after beating Atlanta the previous week -- in Spain.

Yet Cincinnati looked like the team that had spent two weeks preparing.

Now the Steelers have to travel to Philadelphia, where they haven't won since 1965, before turning around to host Denver on Black Friday. McCarthy won't have the luxury of extra preparation time for either matchup.

After what happened against Cincinnati, Steelers fans have every reason to wonder what his coaching staff was doing with the time it already had.

Add us as a preferred source on Google