Anticipation for an eventful Pittsburgh Steelers campaign kicked off Sunday afternoon in spectacular fashion.
With a retooled roster and plenty of offseason buzz, fans hoped to see a more dynamic team on both sides of the ball. And while the offense delivered flashes of excitement, the defense — particularly veteran cornerback Darius Slay — suffered a humbling blow early in the game.
It didn’t take long for the Steelers' newly acquired Pro Bowl duo of Aaron Rodgers and DK Metcalf to find their groove in Arthur Smith’s offensive system.
Rodgers looked poised and in control, while Metcalf quickly established himself as a go-to target. The offense, though not perfect, looked functional more often than not — a welcome change for Pittsburgh fans who’ve endured years of inconsistency.
Unfortunately, the same couldn’t be said for Teryl Austin’s revamped defense.
Coming into Week 1, the assumption was that Austin's unit would have an early advantage. After all, they were facing a familiar quarterback in Justin Fields, whose career has been marked by ups and downs.
But that narrative unraveled quickly as Fields marched down the field with confidence in the first half, picking apart the Steelers' secondary with surgical precision.
When Pittsburgh needed a stop in the first quarter, all eyes turned to veteran cornerback Darius Slay — the 34-year-old expected to bring experience and leadership to a relatively young defensive backfield.
Instead, Slay found himself on the wrong side of a 33-yard bomb from Fields to Jets star receiver Garrett Wilson.
The Pittsburgh Steelers must evaluate their usage of Darius Slay after Week 1
The play was the pin-missile in a strategized, almost surgical attack on Slay — one that exposed his age, speed, and inability to keep up with elite receivers like Wilson. The route was crisp, the throw was perfect, and Slay never had a chance.
As Wilson hauled in the pass and moved the Jets into scoring position, the Steelers' sideline looked stunned.
It was a gut-punching moment for a defense that prides itself on grit and accountability.
Slay, who joined Pittsburgh in the offseason with 28 interceptions under his belt since 2013, was expected to be a stabilizing force in a unit undergoing transition. But Sunday’s performance raises serious concerns about whether the Steelers are asking too much of a player clearly on the back end of his career.
READ MORE: Jets just learned what Steelers fans already knew about Broderick Jones
While his football IQ and experience are undeniable, his physical decline may be too glaring to ignore when lined up against premier young talent.
The Steelers now face a difficult decision: trust that Slay can bounce back, or start preparing a contingency plan in the secondary. One bad game doesn't define a season, but the warning signs are there — and Week 1 was a painful reminder that reputations alone don’t win matchups.
There’s still a long road ahead, and no doubt Slay will have opportunities to respond. But time is ticking. If Pittsburgh wants to compete in a loaded AFC, they’ll need more than just veteran presence — they’ll need production.