Skip to main content

Mike McCarthy must avoid the Steelers trap that doomed Mike Tomlin

ByAllison Koehler
Mike Tomlin (L) and Mike McCarthy (R)
Mike Tomlin (L) and Mike McCarthy (R) | Joe Sargent - Getty Images | Graphic by Allison Koehler

The Pittsburgh Steelers just got shellacked by the Cincinnati Bengals, and if we're being fair, that 38-18 beatdown looked a whole lot like something we've seen before under Mike Tomlin.

The Steelers weren't just beaten Sunday night. They were outplayed in just about every way imaginable. Cincinnati more than doubled Pittsburgh's yardage output, 484 to 222. Joe Burrow threw for 409 yards and four touchdowns, while Ja'Marr Chase ran wild for 231 receiving yards. Pittsburgh's defense had absolutely no answers.

The offense was stagnant. Aaron Rodgers struggled to get anything going, and the Steelers managed just three points through three quarters. By the time DK Metcalf and Pat Freiermuth found the end zone, the game was already out of reach. For a team that had an extra week to prepare, this was a pretty awful showing.

Pittsburgh Steelers need Mike McCarthy to avoid the same mistakes that hurt Mike Tomlin

Mike Tomlin happened to be in the building Sunday night, working his first Steelers game on location as an NBC commentator. He recognized just how badly Cincinnati had outplayed his former team.

Steelers fans didn't need Tomlin to explain what they were watching. We've seen this movie before, and we're beyond tired of the ending.

Remember how Pittsburgh finished the 2024 season? The Steelers were sitting at 10-3 before losing five straight games, including another embarrassing playoff exit at the hands of the Ravens. The 2020 season followed a similar script, with an 11-0 start turning into a late-season collapse.

Those stretches were a huge part of the frustration surrounding Tomlin. His teams could stack wins, but once things started going south, they had a nasty habit of spiraling.

McCarthy was supposed to help change that.

Instead, his offense managed just 120 net passing yards against Cincinnati. Rodgers completed only 15 of 29 passes, and the Steelers' struggling passing attack looked eerily familiar.

Patrick Graham's defense deserves plenty of blame, too. Burrow barely broke a sweat against Pittsburgh's pass rush, and the Bengals scored touchdowns on five of their six red-zone trips. That's simply unacceptable with T.J. Watt and Cameron Heyward still anchoring this defense.

But one ugly loss doesn't mean McCarthy is headed down the same road as Tomlin.

Pittsburgh had won four straight games before Sunday, and McCarthy has already shown he can get this team back on track after a loss. That's something we shouldn't completely dismiss.

But the next few weeks are going to tell us plenty.

McCarthy's next three games will reveal whether the Steelers have really changed

The Steelers are now 6-3, trailing Cincinnati in the AFC North. Their division title chances took a hit, and the schedule isn't doing them any favors.

Pittsburgh travels to Philadelphia next (where it hasn't won since 1965), then faces Denver on a short week, followed by the Houston Texans, who ended their playoff hopes in what became Tomlin's final season. Those aren't exactly opponents you want to see when your offense just got pushed around, and your defense couldn't stop your grandma.

McCarthy doesn't need to win all three games to prove himself. But he does need to show that Sunday wasn't the beginning of another familiar Steelers slide.

Tomlin's biggest problem wasn't that his teams occasionally got embarrassed. Every coach has those games. It was how often Pittsburgh struggled to recover when the season got tougher.

McCarthy just experienced his first major beating as Steelers head coach. How his team responds over the next two or three games will tell fans a lot more about this coaching change than the first eight games did.

Add us as a preferred source on Google