Skip to main content

Steelers stock report entering Week 11 reveals a troubling trend

ByTommy Jaggi
Pittsburgh Steelers cornerback Asante Samuel Jr.
Pittsburgh Steelers cornerback Asante Samuel Jr. | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Pittsburgh Steelers' loss surprisingly didn't hurt their playoff chances, but it was demoralizing nonetheless. Now, this team that once gave us reason to be optimistic is showing why it doesn't resemble a legitimate playoff contender.

The Steelers' latest humiliating loss on Sunday Night Football against the Cincinnati Bengals came with a collection of disappointing (and even downright disgusting) performances. Suddenly, a Pittsburgh team that was previously on a four-game winning streak came crashing back down to earth.

There is hope that these players will turn things around late in the season, but for now, too many prominent players are witnessing their stock trending in the wrong direction.

Pittsburgh Steelers stock report after their Week 10 loss against the Cincinnati Bengals

Patrick Queen: Stock up

Patrick Queen was one of the few bright spots on an otherwise disgraceful Steelers defense. For the third game in a row, Queen has shown up to play, and he might be on the best three-game stretch of his Steelers career.

As the rest of Pittsburgh's defense struggled to contain Joe Burrow and a talented passing offense, Queen allowed just 24 yards on five targets (4.8 yards per target), per Pro Football Focus's advanced stats. He also recorded a whopping 14 total tackles while earning an 81.5 overall grade in Week 10.

Pat Freiermuth: Stock up

The Steelers' offense was abysmal in Week 10 against the Bengals, but it was hardly the fault of Pat Freiermuth. The veteran tight end reeled in two of three targets for 35 yards and a touchdown... and he should have been far more involved in the offense.

Beyond his stats, Freiermuth was getting open. On one play, the savvy tight end dusted his man with a nifty corner-post route and was wide open, but the pressure got to Aaron Rodgers quickly. Watching the all-22 film, Freiermuth was one of the only Steelers weapons getting open, and there were missed opportunities here.

Aaron Rodgers: Stock down

Speaking of Rodgers, things can't get much worse than what we witnessed from him on Sunday Night Football in Week 10. The 42-year-old quarterback showed his age as he was immobile in the pocket and inaccurate with the football.

In his defense, Pittsburgh's receivers were constantly blanketed, and the offensive line collapsed at times. But Rodgers didn't do anything to move the chains until garbage time in the fourth quarter. This was one of the worst performances of his Steelers career, and he's trending in the wrong direction.

Mason McCormick: Stock down

Mason McCormick wasn't having a good game in Cincinnati before the injury, but he's been a staple on the offensive line all year. Sadly, he makes this list due to a gruesome ankle injury suffered in the middle of the game.

McCormick will now have a long road of rehab ahead. He was having a breakout season and is seeking a contract extension in 2027. This could prove to be a big setback for his promising career path.

Asante Samuel Jr.: Stock down

If you wondered if the Pittsburgh Steelers miss Joey Porter Jr., you can be certain that they do now. Asante Samuel Jr. was disgraceful against the Bengals. On just seven targets, the veteran cornerback allowed 135 yards, and for a time, he sat on the bench as rookie Daylen Everette entered the game.

We saw this coming a mile away, as Samuel was benched halfway through the Bengals game back in Week 3 after getting picked on in the first half by Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. Sadly, Samuel has shown to be a limited cornerback who struggles against good receivers.

T.J. Watt: Stock down

Early in the season, Steelers fans were optimistic that we were getting the T.J. Watt of old back. But this hasn't been the case in recent weeks. Though Watt still makes the occasional splash or tipped pass at the line of scrimmage, he struggled mightily in Week 10.

Pittsburgh's star pass rusher couldn't get a lick of pressure against 24-year-old right tackle Amarius Mims. In two games against Mims this season, Watt did not record a single pressure. He was completely erased from this game.

Alex Highsmith: Stock down

Alex Highsmith has been the epitome of consistency in Pittsburgh, but this may have been one of the worst games of his NFL career. The veteran pass rusher logged 44 snaps (32 pass-rush snaps) but couldn't log a pressure while getting involved in just one tackle all game.

Highsmith earned a 42.2 overall grade from Pro Football Focus in Week 10. I'm hardly worried about him, but he was non-existent in the Steelers' biggest game of the season so far.

Robert Spears-Jennings: Stock down

We might quickly be discovering a Robert Spears-Jennings problem the Pittsburgh Steelers didn't know they had. The seventh-round rookie has been impressive at safety since finding a bigger role halfway through the Steelers' Week 4 game against the Browns.

Unfortunately, Spears-Jennings showed his weaknesses in coverage, as he had a few mental lapses that resulted in big plays. I'm not out on him, but his 29.9 PFF grade in Week 10 speaks volumes.

Germie Bernard: Stock down

A few weeks ago, Steelers fans were glowingly optimistic about rookie wideout Germie Bernard. Sadly, the second-round pick has come crashing down to earth in recent weeks.

Bernard was targeted three times in Week 10, but failed to come down with a single catch. There were plays in which Bernard got open, and Rodgers didn't look his way, but these past few weeks, Bernard hasn't made a difference to the Steelers' offense.

Add us as a preferred source on Google